Rent a Car in the Caribbean and Central America 2026 Guide
C
Customs Breeze
April 21, 2026
8 min read
Driving in Caribbean islands, Caribbean car rental tips, is it safe to drive in the Caribbean
If you’re a first-time visitor from the USA, Canada, Europe, or Asia, the idea of renting a car in the Caribbean or nearby mainland countries can feel overwhelming. Driving on the left (or right), confusing insurance, potholes the size of craters, livestock on the road, and aggressive local drivers are real concerns. This is the most comprehensive, up-to-date guide you will find built directly from official 2026 sources, rental company data, and real tourist experiences.
You’ll walk away knowing exactly where renting a car makes sense, how to avoid the most common traps, and whether a private driver might be the smarter (and safer) choice.
Why this guide exists
Renting a car gives you freedom. But in the Caribbean and Central/South America, that freedom comes with hidden risks most tourists discover too late after a near-miss on a mountain road, a surprise $1,200 insurance bill, or a police stop that turns stressful because your license isn’t accepted.
This guide eliminates the guesswork. We’ve pulled together every key fact on driving side, license/IDP rules, insurance, road conditions, real-world behavior, and costs — all current for 2026. No fluff. No outdated 2023 advice.
Key fears we address head-on:
1. Driving on the left when you’ve only ever driven on the right
2. Insurance scams and hidden fees
3. Is it actually safe?
4. When renting a car is a great idea… and when it’s a terrible one
Best Caribbean & Central America Car Rental Guide for 2026 | Customs Breeze
By the end, you’ll have a clear decision framework and actionable steps.
Quick Summary Dashboard
Key takeaway from the dashboard: Left-side driving islands are harder for North American/European drivers. Right-side islands feel more familiar but often have poorer enforcement.
CARIBBEAN SYSTEM BREAKDOWN
A. Left-Side Driving Islands (UK System) – The Majority of Popular Islands
Includes: Bahamas, Jamaica, Barbados, Saint Lucia, Antigua & Barbuda, Grenada, St Vincent & the Grenadines, Dominica, St Kitts & Nevis, Cayman Islands, BVI, Anguilla, Montserrat, Trinidad & Tobago, Turks & Caicos.
-Steering wheel on the right — immediate adjustment needed.
-Roundabouts everywhere — traffic already in the circle has right of way.
-Local temporary permit required on almost every island ($10–$25, usually arranged at rental counter).
-Surprises for tourists: Narrow mountain roads with no guardrails, livestock, sudden speed bumps, and drivers who overtake aggressively.
-Difficulty level: Moderate to hard for first-timers.
-Rental specifics: Most agencies require age 21–25. Many push CDW hard.
-Real-world tip: If you’re from a right-driving country, practice in a quiet parking lot first.
B. Right-Side Driving Islands (EU/LatAm Style)
Includes: Dominican Republic, Cuba, Puerto Rico, Haiti, Aruba, Curaçao, Bonaire, Sint Maarten, Guadeloupe, Martinique.
-Feels familiar to US/EU drivers but enforcement is often lax, motorcycles weave unpredictably, and signage can be poor.
-Difficulty level: Easier adjustment, but higher chaos factor in DR and Haiti.
C. French/Dutch Territories (High-Quality EU Standard)
Includes: Guadeloupe, Martinique, Sint Maarten (Dutch side), Aruba, Curaçao, Bonaire.
-Best road quality in the region.
-Strict enforcement.
-Easiest for European drivers.
INDIVIDUAL DESTINATION PROFILES
Bahamas Drive on left. US/UK license OK for up to 3 months (others need IDP). Minimum rental age 21–25. Seatbelts mandatory. Speed limits in mph. Roundabouts rule the roads — no stoplights on many islands. Watch for livestock. Rental includes basic third-party liability.
Jamaica Left (British-style). US license must be accompanied by IDP. Age 23+ typical. Urban 50 km/h, rural 80 km/h, highways 110 km/h. Compulsory third-party liability. Livestock on rural roads is common. Defensive driving essential.
Barbados Left. Foreign license accepted (IDP recommended if not English). Age 21–25. Excellent road quality for the region. Mandatory third-party liability included. Very tourist-friendly.
Saint Lucia Left. Local temporary driver’s license required (buy at rental counter ~$20). 4x4 strongly advised for interior roads. Scenic but winding mountain routes with blind curves.
Antigua & Barbuda Left. Local permit required (~$20). Flat, easy-to-drive island. Highly recommended for first-timers.
Grenada Left. Temporary local license required. Good roads in tourist areas, but steep hills elsewhere.
Dominica Left. Local permit required. Very mountainous — 4x4 essential. Road quality varies widely.
Costa Rica (detailed profile) Right side. Home license valid (IDP recommended if not in English/Spanish). Minimum rental age 18–21 depending on company. Mandatory third-party liability (SLI) from INS — $10–20/day, included in most rentals. Roads range from excellent highways to pothole-filled gravel. Night driving strongly discouraged. 4x4 required for many popular routes (Monteverde, Osa Peninsula, etc.). Police checks are frequent — carry passport + license.
Panama Right. Foreign license valid 90 days. Mandatory third-party liability. Good highways but flooding common. Zero alcohol tolerance. Carry passport + license at all times.
Belize Right. Foreign license accepted. Highways ~90 km/h, towns ~40 km/h. Unique left-turn rule (pull onto shoulder). High gas prices. Speed bumps everywhere.
Colombia Right. IDP recommended. “Pico y Placa” plate restrictions in major cities. Mountain driving is steep and winding. SOAT (third-party) mandatory.
Suriname Left (Dutch/British influence). Foreign license accepted (IDP recommended). Road quality drops sharply outside Paramaribo. Rural roads often unpaved.
Other quick profiles (full details in dashboard):
-Puerto Rico: Right side, US rules — easiest transition.
-Dominican Republic: Right side but chaotic traffic and motorcycles everywhere.
-Aruba/Curaçao/Bonaire: Right side, excellent infrastructure, very tourist-friendly.
-Cayman Islands: Left side, modern roads, highly recommended.
-Trinidad & Tobago: Left side, IDP recommended, urban congestion high.
INSURANCE – THE SECTION THAT SAVES YOU THOUSANDS
Mandatory everywhere: Third-party liability (covers damage you cause to others). What rental companies sell you:
-CDW – Collision Damage Waiver (reduces your responsibility for vehicle damage)
Credit card insurance myth: Many cards do not cover the mandatory local liability in Costa Rica, Panama, or many Caribbean islands. Always verify in writing.
Strong recommendation: Buy comprehensive travel insurance that covers:
-Medical evacuation
-Personal liability
-Trip interruption
-Theft of belongings from the car
Common scams to avoid:
-Rental agents claiming your credit card coverage is invalid
-“zero deductible” upsells
-Charging for pre-existing scratches you didn’t photograph
Pro move: Take 50+ photos of the car (including undercarriage) at pickup and drop-off.
DRIVING RULES VS REALITY
Official laws exist. Real behavior is different. Expect aggressive overtaking, informal right-of-way, and loose enforcement outside tourist zones. Night driving is the single biggest risk factor across the entire region because of poor lighting, animals, and pedestrians.
SAFETY GUIDE – Biggest Mistakes Tourists Make
-Drifting into the wrong lane (left-side islands)
-Driving at night
-Underestimating potholes/speed bumps
-Assuming local drivers follow the same rules
-Not carrying physical documents
Defensive driving tips:
-Assume every vehicle is about to do something unpredictable
-Keep your tank above half full
-Slow down for blind curves
-Never drink and drive (zero tolerance in many places)
-Gas: $4.30–$7.20 per gallon (highest in Belize & Barbados)
-Insurance: $10–$35/day
-permit: $10–$25 (one-time on many islands)
-Deposit: $500–$2,000 (credit card hold)
-Cheapest overall: Puerto Rico, Trinidad & Tobago, Panama.
-Most expensive: Barbados, Belize, many small islands.
PRO TIPS FROM EXPERTS
-Best car type: SUV or 4x4 for 80% of destinations
-Book early: 3–6 months for peak season (Dec–April)
-Local vs international companies: International (Hertz, Avis) often easier for insurance disputes
-Navigation: Google Maps + offline Maps.me. Landmarks > street names
-Fuel strategy: Fill up before returning the car
ALTERNATIVES TO RENTING A CAR
Many tourists ultimately decide not to rent after reading this guide.
Better options:
-Private licensed drivers (fixed price, no stress, local knowledge)
-Taxis / airport transfers
-Organized tours
CustomsBreeze driver marketplace offers vetted local drivers with clean slug URLs, fixed pricing, and meet-and-greet service — often the safest and most relaxing choice.
FINAL RECOMMENDATIONS
Best places to rent a car: Barbados, Antigua, Cayman Islands, Puerto Rico, Aruba. Worst / most stressful: Dominica, Suriname, rural Haiti, parts of Jamaica at night. Decision framework:
Is it safe to drive in the Caribbean? It can be, with defensive driving and daylight hours only. Night driving is the highest risk.
Do I need an international driving permit (IDP)? Recommended in almost every country. Required in Jamaica (for US licenses), Colombia, and several others.
Is insurance mandatory? Yes — third-party liability everywhere.
Which islands are easiest to drive on? Barbados, Antigua, Cayman Islands, Aruba, Puerto Rico.
Should I rent a car or book a private driver? Depends on your comfort level and itinerary. Many travelers switch to private drivers after one stressful day.
C